- 2024: Finalist for Best Editor, Long Form for the Hugo Award
- 2023: Finalist for Best Editor, Long Form for the Hugo Award
- 2023: Finalist for the Ember Award for Unsung Contributions to the Genre (part of the Igynte Awards, presented by FIYAH Magazine)
- 2022: Winner of the Hugo Award for Best Editor, Long Form
- 2022: Winner of the Publishers Weekly Star Watch Superstar Award